A former administrative associate within Indianapolis Public Schools faces a criminal charge and was found by a special state investigation to have received over $7,000 in reimbursements from a school account for purchases that never arrived.
A State Board of Accounts investigation found that Tiffany Mercado received nine checks between May 2024 and January 2025 from the extracurricular activity account fund for Clarence Farrington School 61 totaling $7,410.
The findings, released Nov. 5, notes Marion County prosecutors already charged Mercado with a Level 6felony for theft of property worth $750 and $50,000. The school’s principal, however, estimated that $9,799 was missing, according to a probable cause affidavit for Mercado's arrest.
Mercado submitted claims for purchases the school never received, including $2,900 for playground sets, $1,182 in food for a staff appreciation lunch, $2,083 in headphones and organizers, $995 in an order for staff T-shirts, and $250 for a training that Mercado could not confirm she attended, according to the report.
Mercado resigned from the district in February 2025 — about one month before School 61 Principal Mitchell Simmons spoke with police to report theft of money from the school’s account, according to the probable cause affidavit. The district also reported the incident to the State Board of Accounts.
Mercado paid $1,845 back to the school before she stopped responding to the principal, according to the auditor report.
Mercado has a warrant for her arrest after failing to show up in court in August 2026. She could not be reached for comment.
An IPS spokesperson did not respond to WFYI’s questions about how the district would recover the funds and whether Mercado was facing disciplinary action when she resigned.
The special investigation concluded that the school had a number of internal control deficiencies that contributed to Mercado receiving reimbursement for purchases that were not made.
District policy requires any purchase above $500 to be approved by the district school board, the investigation noted — a policy that was not followed in the purchase of the playground sets.
Reimbursement to Mercado should also have occurred only after the school received receipts for the goods or services, the auditors said.
IPS district policy requires two authorized individuals to sign each check, which can include the principal and the treasurer for the extracurricular account. District guideline also require vendors to be paid directly.
The investigation concluded that Mercado was allowed to sign checks, which the report said should not have been allowable. Mercado approved at least one of the checks written to herself — $950 for a playground set, according to the SBOA investigation and affidavit.
The school’s assistant principal told police that Mercado was given access to the extracurricular activities account because the school treasurer for the account — a teacher — was on intermittent leave, according to the affidavit.
“The elementary school’s decision to grant Mercado check-signing privileges gave Mercado easier access to reimburse herself for playground equipment that was never received,” the report notes.
In its response to the investigation, the district stated that the theft resulted from “one employee’s deliberate deception and from isolated building-level departures from established district policy by another employee.”
Mercado circumvented some controls by fabricating price quotes and canceling orders after receiving money for them, the district said.
When Simmons contacted the vendor for staff T-shirts, for example, the vendor confirmed that the order was canceled because no payment was received, according to the SBOA investigation.
The State Board of accounts also seeks $5,529 from Mercado from the cost of conducting the special investigation.
It’s unclear who may pay the SBOA for that cost – although the investigation notes that the district had $100,000 in employee theft crime insurance coverage during the time period.
The chief of staff for the SBOA told WFYI that the report has been referred to the attorney general’s office, which pursues legal remedies to recover the money.
Contact WFYI Education Reporter Amelia Pak-Harvey at apak-harvey@wfyi.org.