Lakeisha Smith walks her nieces and nephew to and from their school, Ralph Waldo Emerson School 58, just about every day.
"They like this school and it's a good school to have," Smith said. "It's got a gym, it's got a basketball team… this is the best school that they could ever be at."
But a plan to close School 58 and five others in Indianapolis Public Schools brings instability and uncertainty for families like hers, as IPS works to close a deficit of at least $20 million by shuttering six schools and charging charter schools for previously in-kind services.
As traditional public school families lament potential school closures, parents with the charter-friendly Stand for Children Indiana advocacy group are pushing the district to work with the charter sector to lobby state lawmakers for more funding to help close next school year's deficit.
The closures would usher in yet another period of instability for staff and parents, who just three years ago navigated the closure of six other schools as the district attempted to right-size.
The district estimates the closures would impact about 450 staff at closing and merging schools, who would need to reapply for other roles within the district. Impacted staff would receive priority for positions in the school with which they're merging, but a spokesperson said IPS would not know until June how many open positions would be available for 2027-28.
If approved, the changes would close some of the very schools that absorbed students displaced in the district's last round of closures approved in 2022. It would also act on the closure of the popular Center for Inquiry at Benjamin Harrison School 2, which was originally recommended for closure that same year.
At a school board meeting Thursday, CFI 2 parent Katharine Harris said the school offers a rare environment of a stably enrolled, healthy community.
"IPS cannot expect to close CFI 2 and have the community reconstitute itself next year at CFI 27," Harris said. "Instead, I believe that closure will lead to further enrollment declines and exacerbate the district's own problems."
Stand parents, meanwhile, propose the district use a state charter school grant to help close the deficit.
In a letter delivered to the board on Thursday, the group noted that the grant — awarded to charter schools at $1,400 per pupil — could be used to pay the district back for certain services and help close the budget deficit. The group urged the district to work with the charter sector to lobby lawmakers to retain that funding in the next biennium.
"In the past, we've seen traditional and charter school supporters at odds over existing dollars instead of joining forces to fight for more funding for all children," the letter reads. "As youth and parents, we do not want to see another fight over which public schools or which students get a bigger piece of a pie that is too small to begin with."
The recommended closures of Frederick Douglass School 19, the Center for Inquiry at School 2, Robert Lee Frost School 106, Ralph Waldo Emerson School 58 and Longfellow Middle School — along with the relocation of other programs — would save an estimated $4 million according to the district. The board will vote on the closures Dec. 8.
Closures would boost occupancy at five buildings
The proposed school closures would impact roughly 1,450 students, the majority of whom are Black or Hispanic according to preliminary state enrollment data. All schools except CFI 2 have declined in enrollment from last school year.
The district estimates all proposed changes — including closures and the relocation of three other academic programs — would impact about 3,115 students.
On the northeast side of the district, Robert Lee Frost School 106 parent Branden Johnston said it's a shame to see the school close. But he said he likely won't keep his kindergartener and third-grader in IPS next year.
"If the schools do close, hopefully it's for the better," Johnston said. "Ultimately it'd be nice to see the schools stay open in a more local environment."
The district estimates the mergers would boost occupancy rates at the five schools receiving students impacted by closures. The rates would vary from above 60% at T.C. Howe Middle School, which would absorb Longfellow Middle School, to above 90% at Eliza Blaker Butler Lab School 55, which would absorb Robert Lee Frost School 106.
Closures could spur push for funding at the Statehouse
The changes could unite both traditional and charter school parents in a push for more education funding during the state's upcoming legislative session.
Stand for Children Indiana — which in 2023 opposed a proposed IPS operating referendum without charters receiving a proportional share — has signaled a desire for IPS and charter schools to work together for more funding for English language learners and special education students.
Ada Lemus, a Stand parent advocate whose son has dyslexia, urged the board to work with the charter sector and the newly created Indianapolis Public Education Corporation to push for more special education funding at the Statehouse.
"A child with dyslexia, autism, or other disability should receive strong support, no matter what kind of public school the family chooses," Lemus said.
State law restricts how much money the district can charge Innovation schools for services, like utilities and transportation. The district currently offers major services, like transportation and facilities, to many Innovation schools at no cost.
Stand advocates on Thursday noted the district can work with the charter sector to push for a change to that law, so IPS could receive that $1,400 per-pupil from charters to help cover the cost of these services.
"We believe collaboration can limit cuts and disruption while protecting students," Lemus said. "Our children cannot wait for another year of division."
Contact WFYI Education Reporter Amelia Pak-Harvey at apak-harvey@wfyi.org